I've been touting triple digit silver since 2021. But now that the price of silver has surpassed the century mark per troy ounce, I judge that the case for owning gold may be stronger than the case for owning silver. However, recognizing that there is a significant probability of this prediction being wrong, I'm only going to a 50% silver allocation versus a 50% gold allocation. This keeps me in a good position regardless of which of these precious metals has the greater appreciation in price. And I judge that the price of both silver and gold are headed higher.
In the case of silver, I think the adage that the cure for high prices is high prices may come into play. If the price of silver keeps rising, there could be significant demand destruction. A key driver of the rise in price of silver could evaporate. If the industrial use of silver declines (solar panel usage as an example) the excess consumption versus production that has been in effect since 2021 may reverse. For reference, according to the Silver Institute states:
- Overall, 2025 will see the fifth successive deficit; albeit lower y/y, it is still estimated at a sizeable 95Moz. For 2021-25, this results in a cumulative deficit of almost 820Moz.
The other primary driver in the increase in price of silver is that it is a monetary metal. And given the size of US debt ($35.8 trillion) and the almost certain likelihood of continuing enormous budget deficits, the rational for US investors to buy silver to protect again inflation remains incredibly valid. And time will tell whether this week's events have given added momentum to the "sell America" trade.
GOLD
So while the price of silver is likely to continue on an upward path due to its monetary value, I judge that the pure play monetary metal play, gold, may be a better investment. A huge driver in the increase in the price of gold has been its accumulation by central banks. And central bank buying (40 tons per month according to the World Gold Council) is a bazooka that does not have a silver buyer equivalent. While gold is used for jewelry, dentistry and has industrial applications, these are minimal compared to its purchase as a financial asset.
Thus, I'm reallocating gold to being an equal weigh portion of my investment portfolio versus silver due to it being a more of pure play for protecting myself from US monetary debasement.
CAVEATS
Will I regret reducing my position in silver? Maybe:
- The available supply of above ground silver is very tight. There could be a silver short squeeze that drives the price much higher. I just saw a prediction that it could drive the price to $500 per ounce. That seems a bit out there, but $150 to $300 an ounce is not totally out of the question.
- The market for silver is 1/10th the size of the market for gold and the price is much more volatile. Thus, if the increase in buying demand for silver is anywhere near that of gold, then the increase in the price of silver will outpace that of gold.
Historically, the gold to silver price ratio is 50:1 to 80:1. As if April 2025 it had gone to 100:1, meaning that an ounce of gold was worth 100 ounces of silver. But recently the ratio has compressed back to about 50:1. Given that the ratio in the ground is 7:1 (7 times as much silver), further compression of the ratio is certainly possible, but my guess is that it is headed back toward the middle of the historical range.